/
Qualitative Research Paradigms and Inquiry
Save to my account
Sign up
Qualitative Research Paradigms and Inquiry
Chapter 10
Study
1
Question
How does ontology under postpositivism differ from ontology under social constructivism?
Page 1
Answer
Postpositivism posits that an objective reality exists independent of human perception, though it can only be known imperfectly or probabilistically. Social constructivism asserts that reality is socially created and negotiated through language, discourse, and interpersonal interactions. Memory hook: Picture a stone monument standing outside a clinic window (the fixed postpositivist reality) versus two clinicians sitting inside weaving a colorful tapestry together from their dialogue (the co-constructed constructivist reality).
2
Question
Why cannot quantitative criteria for rigor such as reliability and validity be directly applied to qualitative findings?
Page 6
Answer
Quantitative criteria assume a singular, static reality that can be objectively replicated and measured. In contrast, qualitative research views knowledge as context-dependent, emergent, and deeply tied to specific times and participant experiences. Memory hook: Imagine trying to gauge the depth of an ever-shifting river using a rigid, unbending steel yardstick.
3
Question
How does the primary mode of reasoning in qualitative inquiry contrast with that of traditional quantitative research?
Page 4
Answer
Qualitative inquiry relies primarily on inductive reasoning, developing grounded understanding upward from local contexts and participant experiences. Quantitative inquiry relies on deductive reasoning, testing a priori hypotheses derived from established theory. Memory hook: Picture building a stone tower upward brick-by-brick from the soil (inductive) versus dropping a prefabricated ceiling down to see if it fits (deductive).
4
Question
What primary transformation occurs in the practitioner-scholar role when shifting from postpositivism to critical theory?
Page 2
Answer
The practitioner-scholar moves from an objective, detached observer striving to minimize personal bias into an active transformative intellectual who uses research to critique systemic power structures and advocate for social justice. Memory hook: Think of a clinician trading a sterile white lab coat for an advocate megaphone.
5
Question
What core visual image represents the contrast between postpositivist and constructivist ontologies in qualitative research?
Page 1
Answer
The postpositivist view is represented by a rigid stone monument standing outside the clinic window. The constructivist view is represented by clinicians weaving an evolving tapestry from dialogue inside the room.
6
Question
How does a researcher adopting a postpositivist stance handle personal values, beliefs, and potential bias during data analysis?
Page 2
Answer
The researcher implements bracketing procedures to keep subjectivity in check. They utilize external mechanisms such as inquiry auditors, step-by-step protocols, and consensus coding teams to maintain objective distance from the data.
7
Question
Why does a social constructivist researcher consider bracketing personal values impossible during inquiry?
Page 3
Answer
Constructivism posits that all understanding is inherently relational and interpretive. Because researchers are themselves meaning-making instruments, their personal values, histories, and interactions inevitably co-create the research findings.
8
Question
How does the participant role evolve when transitioning from postpositivist research to participatory action research?
Page 3
Answer
In postpositivist research, participants are informational subjects observed by an objective investigator. In participatory action research, participants become active co-researchers who help analyze data, make interpretations, and apply findings to community action.
9
Question
How does a conceptual framework differ from an exhaustive traditional literature review in qualitative study design?
Page 4
Answer
A traditional literature review aims to exhaustively document all prior empirical knowledge to establish sequential building blocks. A conceptual framework is an active, flexible organization of theories, experiences, and literature directly informing a specific inquiry.
10
Question
Which memory handle captures the difference between the researcher role in postpositivism versus critical theory?
Page 2
Answer
The postpositivist researcher wears a sterile white lab coat to preserve detachment, whereas the critical theorist trades it for an activist megaphone to fight systemic oppression.
11
Question
What trade-off between depth and breadth governs qualitative sample size selection?
Page 5
Answer
Larger sample sizes yield broader findings across individuals but provide less individual depth. Smaller sample sizes sacrifice general breadth to achieve dense, rich, and deeply contextualized understanding.
12
Question
Why are steps testing hypotheses via experimentation omitted from most qualitative studies?
Page 4
Answer
Qualitative inquiry investigates how humans experience and give meaning to real-world phenomena rather than manipulating variables. Because qualitative research explores emergent processes within natural settings, rigid pre-planned experimental hypotheses are absent.
13
Question
How does consensual qualitative research maintain objectivity when analyzing qualitative interview data?
Page 2
Answer
It employs a structured research team that engages in deliberate dialogue to reach consensus on codes. An external inquiry auditor then independently reviews the resulting themes against raw transcripts.
14
Question
What is the defining principle of purposeful sampling in qualitative inquiry?
Page 5
Answer
Researchers deliberately recruit individuals who have specifically experienced, or are currently experiencing, the exact event, process, or cultural phenomenon under investigation.
15
Question
What vivid metaphor represents the mismatch between quantitative criteria and qualitative inquiry?
Page 6
Answer
Using quantitative criteria like reliability and validity on qualitative findings is like trying to measure an ever-shifting river using an unbending steel yardstick.
16
Question
How does hermeneutic phenomenology differ from Moustakas's transcendental phenomenology regarding researcher stance?
Page 7
Answer
Moustakas adopts a postpositivist stance emphasizing bracketing and systematic procedures to achieve objectivity. Van Manen's hermeneutic phenomenology operates within an interpretivist stance, treating interpretation and researcher reflection as intrinsic to uncovering lived meaning.
17
Question
What role does the qualitative research question play across data collection and analysis?
Page 5
Answer
The research question is fluid and emergent rather than fixed. It can be refined, reshaped, or substantially redirected as inductive analysis uncovers unexpected dimensions of the phenomenon.
18
Question
How does dissemination differ between conventional academic research and participatory action research?
Page 3
Answer
Conventional research primarily publishes results in professional academic journals. Participatory action research delivers findings directly back to the participant community to implement concrete local interventions and policy changes.
19
Question
Why do qualitative researchers utilize participant-generated photographs or music during interviews?
Page 6
Answer
Visual or musical artifacts serve as catalysts that elicit nuanced memories, emotional associations, and cultural meanings that participants often struggle to express in direct question-and-answer exchanges.
20
Question
What memory image illustrates the nature of qualitative sampling between depth and breadth?
Page 5
Answer
A wide puddle spreading thin across flat floorboards represents a broad sample with shallow depth, while a deep stone well represents a small sample capturing profound, rich depth.
21
Question
How are clinical diagnostic terms conceptualized through a critical theorist framework?
Page 2
Answer
Diagnostic terms are viewed as potential systems of oppression that risk pathologizing individuals. The counselor helps the client interrogate how these labels reflect societal power dynamics rather than purely internal deficits.
22
Question
What is the primary metaphor qualitative researchers employ to access human meaning?
Page 5
Answer
Researchers employ text as the primary metaphor for human meaning making. This includes spoken words, transcribed interviews, written narratives, and related symbolic expressions.
23
Question
How do qualitative results reports differ from quantitative results sections?
Page 6
Answer
Quantitative reports present statistical tables, test statistics, and numerical values. Qualitative reports present narrative themes, category descriptions, conceptual process models, and direct participant quotations.
24
Question
Why does Patton argue against establishing universal, standardized criteria for qualitative research rigor?
Page 6
Answer
Patton asserts that qualitative inquiry is not monolithic or uniform. Because different traditions stem from fundamentally divergent epistemological stances, each methodology requires its own aligned standard of excellence.
25
Question
What mental picture represents the contrast between traditional literature reviews and conceptual frameworks?
Page 4
Answer
A dusty, towering catalog of every book in a library represents a traditional literature review, whereas a researcher's active, customizable sketchbook represents a conceptual framework.
26
Question
How does counseling practice skill overlap with qualitative researcher competence?
Page 7
Answer
Counselors are specifically trained to facilitate reflexive dialogue, explore nuanced human meanings, build relational rapport, and establish an empathic climate that encourages open disclosure.
27
Question
What does a grounded theory study explore when conducted from a postpositivist perspective?
Page 2
Answer
It explores systematic human processes using explicit, structured procedural steps to generate a theoretical model explaining coping, adaptation, or support seeking.
28
Question
How does weak constructivism differ from strong social constructionism in its focus of inquiry?
Page 3
Answer
Weak constructivism focuses primarily on individual cognitive interpretation and meaning making. Strong social constructionism views meaning as collectively negotiated, emerging entirely through social discourse, culture, and relational systems.
29
Question
Why is the researcher considered the primary instrument in qualitative inquiry?
Page 5
Answer
Data collection and analysis rely on the researcher's direct personal engagement, perceptual filters, communicative competence, and ongoing conceptual synthesis of participant expressions.
30
Question
What memory hook represents how participant involvement shifts during qualitative data analysis?
Page 6
Answer
The shift is represented by moving a participant from behind a glass observation mirror (postpositivism) to sitting side-by-side holding the coding pen (participatory constructivism).